The blistering hot and desert dry Summer 2012: this our fourth time in 25 years to buy / sell a house with the incredibly dynamic MacGill Team. Kate and Mike MacGill are consummate professionals: incredibly experienced, boundlessly creative, and with 24/7 unconditional dedication and loyalty to their clients. After decades in the business the MacGills have seen it all and they are better than ever – incredibly deserving of the high regard and respect they have in the industry. This particular round of real estate adventures for us was extremely challenging – selling and buying simultaneously in a rough economic market. Kate and Mike continually stepped up to – and beyond – the daily complex web of challenges, changes and complications, guiding us through every step of the madness with trustworthy advice, personal attention, recommendations and suggestions. Their attention to our every question, concern, etc., made us feel so incredibly safe and supported – as if we were their only clients !!  – Thanks to Kate and Mike, it all turned out great. There is NO WAY this adventure would have had such a happy ending without the MacGills. Thank you, guys, for your tireless ‘above and beyond the call of duty’ attention to our family.

Mike and Miho




We just wanted to say thanks for all your hard work and patience throughout our first home buying experience.  We love our new neighborhood!  We’ve already walked through the neighborhood, met several neighbors, walked on the Monon and to the Monon Center.  Even our dog seems right at home! Hope all is wll.  I attached a pic of us in front of the new house.




Hi, Kate and Mike,

This is the first time I have had a chance to tell you how overjoyed I am about the sale of One West.  It has been such a long haul and very stressful for me.  Tell me not to worry because the buyer is not going to change his mind!  Best to you both,



Kate and Mike,

We both wanted to thank you for your exceptional realty services in selling and buying our homes.  A special thanks goes to Kate for her awesome negotiating with Donna, and also showing us houses not yet on the market at VOWC.  We are so thankful all of our realty deals were successfully completed.  Later, we will have you up to see our house with new touches!  Hope to see you soon  Thank you for everything.


Chris and Bill



Mike and Kate,

Thank you! We are so glad that you went out of your way to serve us.  You showed the true meaning of a Christian.  We thank you for all that you have done for us.  May God truly bless the MacGill family in all that you do.  Love,

Mike and Catrina


Kate and Mike,

Thank you so much for all your help with buying our new home on 57th Street and selling our home on Park Ave.  We appreciate all the hard work you did for us.  I’m certain you made some behind the scenes efforts that I did not see and I thank you for those as well.

Your deep knowledge of the local real estate market, high standard of professionalism and consistent level of personal attention every step of the way distinguishes you in the real estate market.  We will definitely refer you to anyone we talk to who is looking to buy a home.  We wish you well in all that you do.

Donna, Craig and Marissa



Dearest-dearest Kate and Mike-

You precious souls-I just will never be able to thank you enough for making it possible for me to have my lovely condo-you were soo patient w/me to say nothing of handling Chase Bank!!! The cushions for the screened in porch are going to be perfect! Mary Anne and Meredith saw them yesterday.  See what I mean-your thoughtfulness is beyond belief and I’m ready to “tell the world”!  God love you

Mary Alice

You are so cute-thanks for cheering me up after the loss of “our house”–I know God has a better plan-can’t wait to see it & appreciate where He has us going to… XOXO


Dear Michael,
I’ve written this recommendation of your work to share with other LinkedIn users.

Details of the Recommendation: “When looking for a realtor one looks for attributes such as market knowledge, creativeness, professionalism, being punctual, and having integrity. From my experience with Mike MacGill and the MacGill Real Estate team I have received a servicing level above and beyond expectations. I continue to receive excellent services from the MacGill team even many years after using their realtor services to sell and purchase our home. I would recommend no one else to provide realtor services. The MacGill Real Estate Team is associated with the F. C. Tucker Company and have 27 years of combined experience and have sold in excess of $165 Million in career sales. Please refer to their website: for a complete list of services.”
Service Category: Real Estate Agent
Year first hired: 2006
Top Qualities: Great Results, Expert, High Integrity

Scott A.

Kate and Mike,

Thank you so much for all your amazing efforts in selling our home.  We are forever greatful.  You have allowed us the opportunity to move on together and that won’t be forgotten.  Thanks again.

Jessie, Mike & Audrey


I cannot thank you enough for your continued guidance, leadership and support throughout this entire process.  It has been an absolute pleasure working with you and hope our paths cross again.  I appreciate all you have done to make me comfortable and find my 1st home! I couldn’t be happier and am eager to get settled into my new home.  A million and one thanks to you!!

With gratitude,


Dear Mike and Kate,

Thank you.  We are gradually getting settled in our new little home. It is very comfortable-so good for us not to have steps to climb.  Thanks to you both for the help you have given us in this major transition in our lives.  You were very supportive to us and hard working to get the business of the house sold so smoothly.

Thank you for the bottle of wine for our celebration and a very special thank you for the watercolor of our home on Spicewood Ct.  It is a treasure for us to keep and to remember the many happy years we had in that home.

We look forward to a visit from you soon-when it is convenient for you.


Bill and Pat

Dear Kate and Mike-

A note of thanks!  This is very late in getting to both of you but Bill and I could not go without telling you how appreciative we were of everything you did to help us find our house.  Needless to say, we were a little frustrated by everything we had been through and suddenly, everything seemed so much easier.  Thanks again for taking us under your wings!

Bill and Julie

Dear Kate & Mike,

I didn’t want to let another day go by without congratulating you on being selected 37th by the Indianapolis Business Journal for their All Star Agents.  The success that you have achieved has come through your hard work, commitment and your dedication.

I personally want to thank you for being a part of the Tucker Comapny and for everything that you do for me.  Here’s hoping that the remaining months of the year will be outstanding for you.

Best wishes,

Jim Litten
F. C. Tucker Company

Todd and I want to thank you so much for all the time, energy, caring and more you put in to helping us find our home. We could not have done it without you and are so appreciative. We love living here!

Anne and Todd

Kate and Mike,

Thank you so much for our housewarming gift.  You certainly did not have to do that, but we are truly appreciative.  And I am especially thankful that I get to throw away all of those plastic cups I’ve been keeping since college.  Although this process can be stressful at times, its been comforting to know you two have both been through this process many time and had our best interests in mind. We’ll always remember this first house and we will always remember how helpful you two were in helping us reach the finish line.  THANK YOU!

Brian and Libby

John and I can’t thank you enough for, literally and figuratively, running from house to house in search of the perfect one.  We are also grateful for your honesty.  We are excited with our choice!! And, to top it off, so is Noah!
See you soon!

John and Kim

Thanks again for all of your hard work in getting us into our new house. We absolutely love it and can’t wait to move in and make it our own. You were amazing throughout the entire process and I’m so glad Lizzie recommended you to us. She was right – you are the best. :-)

I hope we can stay in touch even though the house buying portion is over for us! We’d love to have you and Michael over this spring – once we’re moved in, we’ll let you know and hopefully you guys can swing by and see what we’ve done with the place.

You’ve really been so wonderful to us, and to me especially. You’ve kind of been like my mom away from home (I hope that doesn’t prematurely age you since I’m a little older than your kids!), and you’ve also become a friend. Thanks for all of your guidance and patience. I don’t know how we would have done it without you and Michael (and Alex…credit should go to him, too, since he saw the house in the beginning)!

Hope you have a wonderful weekend!

Warm regards,
Katie M

Thank you for making our first homebuying experience great! We appreciate your expertise, honesty and all the hardwork you did for us. We love our house and look forward to seeing you in the neighborhood!
Abbie and Ryan

Talking to you on the phone last night made us happy we chose you as our realtor. -Maureen

I wanted to say thank you again for the generous donation. I can’t thank you enough for helping me raise the money for the United Christmas Service. Your support means so much to me. Wishing you a very Merry Christmas and a blessed New Year.


Truly outstanding job Kate…. as I sit here and think -I don’t know if ever we have been so taken care of and
walked through this process- as we are with you and it is TRULY appreciated!!


Thank you so much for everything you have done for us. Thank you for making multiple trips to our condo over the past few years to help us get it ready for market. Thank you for taking us around looking at homes even when we weren’t quite ready. Thank you for taking us to even more homes when we were ready to buy. Thank you for being our advocate withe the buyers of our condo and the sellers of our new home. Thank you for caring for our well being and our financial investment. The list goes on and on. Most of all, thank you for being our friend. We absolutely love our new home and you made the entire process easy and more fun. You’re the best Kate.

Lizzie and Tony

Derek and I wanted to take this opportunity to thank you for not only selling our house but doing it in (-1) days. As our most valuable asset, we appreciated how much time, effort and importance you placed on preparing our property to sell. Your wonderful ideas to add hanging lights in the kitchen and installing shelving in the basement for storage made a huge impact and certainly assisted in us commanding almost the full asking price for the house.

Since this was our first experience with selling a home, we were fortunate to rely on your guidance and expertise throughout the entire journey. In addition, your strong and positive network with related professionals and businesses (Inspector, Contractors, & Roofing Companies) streamlined the process and saved us a lot of time.

We cannot thank you enough for going above and beyond everyday to help keep our stress level to a minimum. With Derek starting a new job in Kentucky, he relied on me to manage all of the details leading up to our move. I can say with a 100% certainty that no other Real Estate agent would have come over at 9:45 PM to help calm my nerves, give me a hug of support, and say “Let me worry for you”. We are very blessed to have had to pleasure to work with your fabulous team.

You kept your promise of giving us 200% and that is what got us to the closing table. MacGill Team, you exceeded our expectations, and we are forever grateful!

Derek and Kim

I can never thank you enough for your guidance and expertise in helping bring about the sale of my condo. You always took the “high road” and helped me through some of the emotion and anger that I seemed to continuously encountered. You are masterful professionals who I will always view as great friends. Best to you always.


We want to once again say a big thank you for all your hard work with our home sale and purchase. You both made the experience very educational and fun for us. For that we are forever grateful as you both really helped us through those stressful moments.

We love the new home! We’ve already started patching some grass and hanging lots of new curtain rods. It feels like home. we wish you both the best and ask that you please stay in touch.

Brian & Lindsey

Thank you both for your excellent service.


Thank you so much for all your help in starting a new life for our family. We love our home and hope to never move. Please know that you made a dream come true an we are grateful.

Sarah & Mike

Real Estate sales is a highly competitive business. REALTORS® don’t usually recommend or praise their competition. Granted, we work together  to accomplish the goal of our respective client; but we don’t generally have celebratory cocktails afterwards. Heck, we may even offend or irritate the other agent.

I’ve been known to buck tradition, so I’ll start the year with a praise for the agent team who represented the sellers on a recent transaction. When you work with truly professional agents, who share the same philosophy of client care as you do, you understand and respect their position for their client. While you may not always agree, each agent knows the other is doing the job they were hired to do.

Many thanks for a job well done to Kate and Mike MacGill at FC Tucker.

On of the very best home buying experiences that I have had in the last 30 years. A really great team you have at Tucker. Thanks!


I wanted to reiterate how helpful you guys have been and how much I appreciated the extra mile you guys have put in. I am walking away from this like I was well taken care of and looked out for. I wouldn’t waste my time saying that if it wasn’t true. My sister even said she wishes her realtor was as helpful as you guys have been, when she bought and sold her houses. I know if she ever moved again, she would be in contact with you. I will be sure to mention, and highly recommend you guys to anyone I know that might need a realtor in the future. Thanks again!


Thank you so much for all your help. It seemed like such a long process and I’m very luck and happy that you guided me through it. I appreciate your patience and diligence.


You made it easy for us. Wish I was buying a house in Indy so I could give you our business


Today my wife and I closed on the sale of our home and the purchase of a home. We would like to express to you our opinion that Kate and Mike MacGiII went above and beyond what is generally expected from real estate professionals in the overall handling of both the sale and purchase processes.

We selected Kate to be our agent due to our experience with her outstanding performance in the sale of a previous residence on Washington Blvd. about 11 years ago. Due to the downturn in the realty market in the recent past it was an arduous process and it took about 15 months to sell our home. Kate and Mike were consistently positive in their approach and kept “plugging away” with open houses, showings and positive and constructive suggestions to improve the marketability of the house.

F. C. Tucker Company is fortunate to have individuals like Kate and Mike MacGiII representing them in the real estate market.

James and Sherry

Thank you for taking the time to recognize Kate and Mike MacGill.

We pride ourselves in providing the very best in real estate services and know this only can be accomplished through the commitment of dedicated professionals like the MacGill’s. Your letter indicates that you have been a long time fan of Kate, having used her services several years ago in the purchase of your former residence. Clearly, her lifetime commitment to serving your real estate needs and remaining in contact was a benefit to both of you.

As you know and experienced, her service increased when Mike joined her. Their joint commitment to our profession, knowledge of the business and market led to your recent successful transactions.

We wish you much happiness in your new home and again thank you for taking the time to recognize Kate and Mike. We are proud to be associated with them.

Fred C. Tucker, III

Thanks again for all your hard work and watch over my place! You are very nice people and I’m lucky to know you. I don’t know what I would do without both of you. You are two of the best people I have ever known. Thanks again, – Kevin

Thank you both for relieving me of this responsibility. You were both wonderful to work with & I sincerely thank you for your time & efforts.

I received notice from Marion County that the reconciliation bill is due. Perhaps you can ask the new owners agent to alert him that this payment is due. Thanks again for helping me


Words cannot describe how much we have enjoyed working with you. Your expertise, guidance and compassion are completely one of a kind. You have helped us begin to feel that Indy can definitely become home.

– Nate, Kate, Ethan and Zach

We are so pleased that you and Mike were our real estate agents. Happy Thanksgiving and Merry Christmas. God love you and Mike.

– Jeanne Monahan

Thanks for all your efforts to “pull off” the sale of my uncle’s home in this challenging market!

– Jim


I just received a voice mail from Donna at Windridge and she said they will cover the cost of repairs to the foundation so I will start the process to get the money back to you.

Thanks, you guys are awesome. It would have never occurred to me to look to Windridge for that expense. – Rick

I was thinking how sweet you are to everyone— after listening to you, bits and pieces, and your conversations on the phone yesterday to your friends. You are a terrific person and dear friend to be so kind to everyone. You work so hard (and most of the time for free!) I truly believe God will continue to bless you because of your goodness. I just had to tell you how wonderful you are not only to others, but also to me.

– Shelly

I don’t know where to begin to thank you. I’ve had very little experience with REALTORS but I do know that what you did for us was way off the chart and far beyond the “call of duty.” I so much appreciated the constant feedback. You made us feel as if you were selling a million dollar home rather than that little home! You are the best at what you do– a true professional–but most importantly is your genuine kindness and compassion– those qualities that come from your heart and make you an incredible person. I hope our paths cross again in the future. Until then, I wish you much success and happiness.

– Martha

This is a long over-due note to thank you both so much for all your help with the purchase of our new home. We appreciate all you did for us— your great advice and your sense of humor through it all! Your generous gift card for a much needed night out was the icing on the cake.

– Beth and Larry

Our lunch time was special and delightful, you are a “special lady” to me, thank you for being part of my life.

– Rosanne

Our new beautiful house is becoming our home. A big thank you to you and Michael. We know you two are the best. It is always a pleasure to work with you.

–Lori and Rick

We wanted to send you this long over-due note to let you know how much we appreciate all your help with the purchase of our lake place. All of your knowledge and experience have been invaluable to us. Not to mention all the time you put in driving up and back! We just think you guys are the greatest.

– Beth and Larry

We wanted to thank you both so much for all your hard work and patience while helping us find our house. We are very happy here – and appreciate all you have done to make that happen. We will certainly recommend any of our friends to you in the future.

– Kiersten and Ryan

We have our house and appreciate all the big and little things (mostly big) you did to help us get here. We had no idea what REALTORS go through to sell a property. We have a feeling that most REALTORS don’t work as hard as the MacGill Team does. Just saying thank you doesn’t seem enough, but we do thank you for sharing your time and expertise with us. You two are the best.

– Sarah and Jeff

Congratulations on your amazing milestone of $100 million in career sales! It does not come as a surprise to me because you both are wonderful at what you do. We were blessed to have you both help us with our sale and buy of our new home. Thank you for being you! I tell everyone of what you do. You have a lifetime supporter.

– Scott and Tina

Thank you so much for your great service over the last year! We love our new home! We are getting settled and starting on some projects which already make it seem like “ours”. Thanks also for the kitchen herbs. Thanks again.

– Stephanie and Eric

We knew from the first time we looked at your website that you would be great for us and you have been so perfect!  Thank you for finding our 1st home for us-we can’t thank you enough!  This process has been so much easier than we had thought it would be.  You said, in the beginning that if we got the house, it would be a fit from God-and that it truly is!  You are great at what you do and we appreciate you so much. Warmly,

Sarah & Andy